Breed and weight limits and your emotional support animal
A pit bull, a German shepherd or a 90 pound Lab can still be an emotional support animal. Whether a landlord has to make an exception depends on your specific animal, your state, and what changed at HUD in 2026.
A breed or weight limit in a lease is a pet rule, and an ESA request asks the landlord to make an exception to pet rules because of a disability. Fair housing law has long been applied to require an individual look at your actual animal, its behavior and history, rather than a breed list or a number on a scale. A landlord can refuse an animal that would pose a direct threat or cause substantial damage, but that judgment is supposed to rest on the specific animal.
2026 added a complication. HUD's May 2026 enforcement memo said the federal agency no longer expects housing providers to extend to untrained ESAs, as a category, the accommodations it expects for trained assistance animals. That changes only where HUD's own fair housing office finds cause. It did not change the Fair Housing Act, private lawsuits remain available, and some states say plainly that blanket breed or size limits cannot decide an assistance animal request.
Here is how breed and weight rules play out now, which states go further, and how to make a request that gets your animal judged on its own record.
Why blanket breed and size rules fall short
The Fair Housing Act treats it as discrimination to refuse reasonable accommodations in rules, policies, practices or services when they may be necessary to give a person with a disability an equal opportunity to use and enjoy a home. A breed list is exactly that kind of rule. The same law says a landlord does not have to rent to someone whose tenancy would be a direct threat to the health or safety of others or would result in substantial physical damage to others' property.
As agencies and courts have generally applied that exception, breed alone is weak evidence. A landlord who can point to a specific bite history or documented aggression stands on much firmer ground than one who points to a list. Other federal rules lean the same way: airlines may not refuse a service dog because of its breed, and the ADA does not let businesses exclude service dogs based on stereotypes about breeds.
Weight limits work similarly. A 25 pound cap is designed for pets in general, not for a particular animal that a professional has found you need. The fair question is whether this animal, in this home, can be kept safely and without undue burden.
What changed at HUD in 2026
In September 2025, HUD withdrew its 2020 assistance animal notice along with older guidance. On May 22, 2026, its fair housing office permanently rescinded that guidance and issued an enforcement memo. The memo says HUD will find reasonable cause in animal cases only when the animal is trained to do disability related work or tasks, and that requests for untrained ESAs are not presumptively reasonable.
For breed and weight rules, that means a federal complaint about an untrained ESA turned away for its size or breed is unlikely to lead HUD's fair housing office to find cause. It does not mean the landlord is automatically in the clear. You can still bring a private lawsuit under the Fair Housing Act within two years, and state agencies enforce their own laws, many of which are broader than current federal enforcement.
For a trained psychiatric service dog, the 2026 memo treats accommodation requests as presumptively reasonable, which makes a breed or weight rule much harder to apply against it.
States that address breed and size directly
Some states have answered this question in their own words. A few examples:
| State | What it says |
|---|---|
| Maryland | The Commission on Civil Rights' 2026 ESA guidance says rejecting an ESA based solely on its species or breed is generally evidence of unlawful discrimination, and that stereotypes about breeds cannot support a direct threat denial. |
| Vermont | The Human Rights Commission lists limits on the breed, type, size or weight of assistance animals among the things a landlord cannot impose. |
| New Jersey | In Players Place II v. K.P. (2024), the state Supreme Court required a condominium with a 30 pound pet limit to evaluate a resident's request for a 63 pound emotional support dog under the Law Against Discrimination, shifting the burden to the association to prove the request unreasonable once the resident showed a disability and need. |
| West Virginia | State law defines assistance animals to include support animals under 150 pounds, and denials need credible, individualized evidence about the specific animal's conduct. |
You can read Maryland's ESA guidance and Vermont's assistance animal page directly. Other states rely on general accommodation duties, so check your state page, or see the details for Maryland and New Jersey.
When the landlord points to insurance
Some landlords say their insurance policy excludes certain breeds. That can be a real constraint, but it is a claim worth checking rather than simply accepting. Maryland's guidance says a housing provider generally cannot deny an ESA because its insurance does not cover animals, and that insurers also have a duty to accommodate reasonable requests.
Elsewhere, ask politely for three things in writing: the policy language, confirmation that the carrier would actually cancel coverage or raise costs because of your animal, and whether comparable coverage without the exclusion is available. A landlord who has thought this through can usually answer quickly.
You can also offer to carry renters insurance with pet liability coverage. Offer it rather than accept it as a condition, because some states limit what a landlord can require. Illinois, for example, bars special liability insurance for an approved assistance animal, and New Jersey's civil rights division says a landlord may not require added renters insurance for an ESA. Our guide to renters insurance and ESAs covers what that coverage usually includes.
City and county breed laws are a separate question
A landlord's breed list is different from a local ordinance. Some cities and counties still have breed specific dog laws, and those apply to residents regardless of what a lease says. Under the ADA, local governments with breed bans must make exceptions for trained service dogs unless a particular dog poses a direct threat. For an ESA, the local ordinance may still apply.
Many states have barred local breed specific rules altogether, so the answer depends heavily on where you live. Before you move with a breed that some places restrict, check the city or county animal ordinance as well as the lease.
Condominium and homeowners associations are covered by fair housing law too, which is why the New Jersey case involved a condo board. If you rent a unit in an association, send your request to both the landlord and the board, since either one may enforce a size or breed rule.
How to ask for an exception that gets an individual look
Put your request in writing and give the landlord something concrete to assess:
- Send your ESA letter with a short note asking for an exception to the breed or weight rule as a reasonable accommodation.
- Attach vaccination and local license records, and spay or neuter records if you have them.
- Add evidence of behavior: a reference from a previous landlord, a note from a trainer, or a basic obedience certificate such as the AKC Canine Good Citizen.
- Offer to introduce your dog to the manager, on a leash, so they can see how it behaves.
- Propose sensible conditions, such as keeping the dog leashed in common areas.
- Ask the landlord to explain in writing if it believes your specific animal poses a direct threat, and why.
The note itself can be short. Something like this works: "I am requesting a reasonable accommodation to the building's breed and weight policy so that my emotional support dog, Bruno, can live with me. I have enclosed my letter, his vaccination records and a reference from my previous landlord, and I am glad to answer any questions about him."
That last step matters. A decision based on your animal's actual record is lawful in a way that a decision based on a list may not be, and asking for reasons in writing keeps the process on that footing.
Ask to be judged on your dog's record, not its breed. A fair process can answer that request. A breed list cannot.
If the answer is still no
Ask for the denial in writing with the reasons, and ask whether the landlord would consider an alternative, such as a different unit or added conditions. Then choose your next step:
- File with your state or local fair housing agency, which applies state law and may protect ESAs more broadly than current federal enforcement.
- File with HUD within one year of the denial, keeping in mind that HUD now reviews animal cases under its 2026 standard, which favors trained animals.
- Get advice from a fair housing organization or a tenant attorney about a private lawsuit, which generally must be filed within two years.
Our guide to when a landlord can deny an ESA walks through each route. If you do not have a letter yet, the free assessment is the first step, and a professional licensed in your state decides whether a letter is appropriate. FetchMyESA never guarantees approval, and you get a full refund if no letter is issued.
Ready for your letter? If your dog's breed has made you nervous about asking, the free assessment is a calm place to start, and the record you build from there does the rest. Start the free assessment, or read what goes into an emotional support animal letter.
Questions people ask
Can a landlord deny my ESA because of its breed?
It depends on your state and your animal. Fair housing law has long been applied to require an individual assessment of the specific animal rather than a breed list, and states such as Maryland and Vermont say blanket breed rules should not decide assistance animal requests. HUD's 2026 memo narrowed federal enforcement for untrained ESAs, but private lawsuits and state agencies remain available.
Do weight limits apply to emotional support animals?
A weight limit is a pet rule, and an ESA request asks for an exception to pet rules. Vermont's Human Rights Commission says landlords cannot limit the size or weight of assistance animals, and New Jersey's Supreme Court required a condo's 30 pound limit to give way to an individual analysis. In other states, the answer turns on whether the specific animal can be kept safely in that home.
What if the landlord's insurance excludes my dog's breed?
Ask for the policy language in writing and whether the insurer would actually cancel or raise costs because of your animal. Maryland's civil rights commission says a provider generally cannot deny an ESA because its insurance does not cover animals. You can offer to carry your own renters liability coverage, but some states, such as Illinois, bar landlords from requiring special insurance.
Do breed restrictions apply to psychiatric service dogs?
Trained service dogs get stronger protection. Airlines may not refuse a service dog because of its breed, the ADA requires local breed bans to make exceptions for service dogs unless a specific dog poses a direct threat, and HUD's 2026 memo treats housing requests for trained animals as presumptively reasonable. A breed rule is much harder to apply to a task trained dog.
This guide is general information, not legal or medical advice. Rules change and vary by state.
More on this topic: landlords, leases and fees
All guides on this topic- Can you have an emotional support animal in a no pets apartment?
- How to hand your landlord an ESA letter, with a sample email
- How to write a reasonable accommodation request letter for your ESA, with a sample
- ESA form for landlord requests
- Can a landlord verify an ESA letter?
- Can a landlord ask about your disability when you request an ESA?
- Pet screening platforms and your ESA letter
- How to add your ESA letter to PetScreening
- ESA pet fees and deposits by state
- Can you have more than one emotional support animal?
- Renters insurance and your emotional support animal
- Can you be evicted for having an emotional support animal?
- What to do if your ESA request is denied, and how to file a fair housing complaint
- ESA rules for landlords and property managers in 2026
- Your building was sold
